Alyssa & Tyler
Alyssa’s friend Mary urged her to sign up for a dating website and that’s where Alyssa met the love of her life, Tyler. As Nev and Max help Alyssa, they begin to wonder who lurks behind the Tyler profile.
What Kind of Catfish Are You?
Nev talks about the different types of catfish, including cheaters, scammers and revenge artists.
Jose & Jay
Jasmine writes to Nev and Max asking for help for a “friend.” But they’re perplexed when Jasmine drops a bombshell revelation: they’ve helped her friend before! Who is Jasmine’s mysterious friend and how do Nev and Max know him?
Nicole & Nicole
For years, Nicole’s pictures have been stolen to make fake profiles, one of which has been catfishing 27-year-old Ryan for 10 years.
Robin desperately wants to meet her hunky, long-distance love in person; Nev and Max agree to help her hunt him down, but what they uncover turns out to be much more than Robin bargained for.
Robert & Ashleigh
After being paralyzed as a teenager, Robert meets Ashleigh online and they fall in love; with news he may not have much longer to live, Robert asks Nev and Max to bring Ashleigh to him.
April & Dean
After meeting in a chat room seven years ago, a woman is eager to find someone before they disappear.
Kelsie & Brandon
After years of endless excuses, a woman wants Nev and Max to find out who her online Romeo really is.
Johnny & Connor
Nev and Max are asked to help track down a missing online love, but Nev and Max discover a former catfish is involved.